The intellectual matrix for writing a book on feminine profiles of immigrant women in America could be "Discovering
Reality" ed. Sandra Harding and Merrill B. Hintikka (University of Delaware ) D. Reidel
Publishing Company ix-xix.
As mentioned, my
immediate thoughts on profiling immigrant women would demand not only a
previously established metaphysics of gender whereby men and women are equally
human but irreducibly dissimilar as relations: the male being self-gift as
donation, the female being self-gift as reception. To do that, you need a
phenomenology of the gender as donation and reception, which is a phenomenology
of relation, and
therefore a new metaphysic
of relation (as opposed
to a metaphysic of "substance"). The key epistemological insight is experience. Experience
is a dimension of the subject,
whereas the received metaphysics is always of the object (Aristotle). The key to this
phenomenological metaphysics is Karol Wojtyla's "Acting Person," and
the essays in his "Person and Community" (Peter Lang).
Harding and Hintikka
write: "What counts
as knowledge must be grounded on experience. Human experience differs
according to the kinds of activities and social relations in which humans
engage. Women's experience systematically differs from the male experience upon
which knowledge claims have been grounded. Thus the experience on
which the prevailing claims to social and natural knowledge are founded is,
first of all, only partial human experience only partially understood: namely,
masculine experience as understood by men. However, when this experience
is presumed to be gender-free - the resulting theories,
concepts, methodologies, inquiry goals and knowledge-claims distort
human social life and human thought."
Therefore, there must
be a feminist "deconstruction project" in which it is shown that
"masculine perspective on masculine experience have shaped the most
fundamental and most formal aspects of systematic thought in philosophy and in
the social and natural sciences...." It must be shown how there must be a
revaluation of "Aristotle's biology and metaphysics, the
very definition of 'the problems of philosophy' in Plato, Descartes, Hobbes and
Rousseau, the 'adversary method' which is the paradigm of philosophic
reasoning, contemporary philosophical psychology, individuation
principles in philosophical ontology, functionalism
in sociological and biological theory, evolutionary theory, the
methodology of political science, Marxist political economy,
and conceptions of 'objective inquiry' in the social
and natural sciences."
So, there must be a
"reconstructive" experience
of what is uniquely feminine as equal (if not more so) but irreducibly
dissimilar (receptive as opposed to donative), and therefore arrive at a more
adequate and integrally human experience.
No comments:
Post a Comment